The annuity exclusion ratio splits each fixed payout from a non-qualified annuity into a slice that returns your own money and a slice that is taxed. This page is for people about to start payouts, including those who may receive them in India or Canada. Use the Two-Slice Payment Check at the end. General information only.
How the annuity exclusion ratio is figured
| Step | Plain meaning | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Investment | Premiums minus earlier excluded receipts; a refund or period-certain feature lowers it first | IRC 72(c)(1); Pub. 939 |
| Expected return | Yearly payment times the Table V multiple (money paid after June 1986; age 66 = 19.2), or total fixed-term payments. Monthly payments starting one month after the starting date need no adjustment | IRC 72(c)(3); Reg. 1.72-5, 1.72-9 |
| Death | Unrecovered investment becomes an itemized deduction; a survivor keeps the original percentage | IRC 72(b)(3); Pub. 939 |
When the payee lives in India or Canada
| Payee | U.S. rule | Treaty text |
|---|---|---|
| U.S. citizen or green-card holder abroad | Generally taxed on worldwide income; generally cannot opt out of withholding on periodic payments sent abroad | India treaty Art. 1(3) saving clause; Art. 1(4) spares only paragraphs 2 and 6 of Art. 20 |
| Nonresident alien in India | 30 percent withheld on the gross U.S.-source payment unless a treaty exempts it; Form W-8BEN goes to the payer | Art. 20(1): taxable only in the payee's country; Art. 20(4): periodic sums |
| Nonresident alien in Canada | Same 30 percent default | Art. XVIII(2)(b): U.S. tax capped at 15 percent of the part the U.S. taxes; periodic payments only |
How it works in numbers (invented example)
Sunita, 66, puts $140,000 of after-tax money into a life-only annuity paying $800 a month ($9,600 a year), first payment a month after the starting date.
- Expected return: $9,600 times 19.2 = $184,320. Ratio: 140,000 / 184,320 = 0.7595, rounded to 0.760.
- Each year: $7,296 excluded, $2,304 taxable. After 19 years $138,624 is excluded; year 20 excludes the last $1,376; from year 21 everything is taxable.
- Death after 9 years: $65,664 excluded, leaving $74,336 as an itemized deduction.
- Were she a Canadian resident with no U.S. status and the treaty applied: default withholding 30 percent of $9,600 = $2,880 a year unless the payer holds her treaty claim; treaty cap 15 percent of $2,304 = $345.60.
Planning points
People starting payouts often consider:
- Comparing life-only, joint-and-survivor and period-certain payouts. Trap: refund features lower investment before the ratio.
- Keeping premium records (box 5 of Form 1099-R reports investment recovered).
- Remembering that taxable payments count toward Social Security taxation and, two years later, Medicare premium surcharges.
- Filing treaty paperwork before the first payment abroad (India treaty, Canada treaty). Whether a payment is "periodic" is a facts question.
The Two-Slice Payment Check
- Starting date and age fixed?
- Investment confirmed, including any refund feature?
- Ratio worked to three decimals?
- Slices match the Form 1099-R?
- Payee abroad: treaty paperwork filed?
Back to the annuities hub.
Frequently asked questions
Does the exclusion ratio apply to partial withdrawals?
No. It covers only amounts received as an annuity.
Does the excluded slice continue forever?
No. For annuities starting after 1986 it ends once investment is recovered, and payments are then fully taxable.
Does an IRA annuity follow this ratio?
Not exactly. Employer-plan annuities often follow the Simplified Method, while IRAs have rules of their own (retirement accounts page).
Official sources
- IRC section 72, Annuities (Cornell LII)
- IRS Publication 939, General Rule for Pensions and Annuities
- IRS Publication 515, Withholding on Nonresident Aliens and Foreign Entities (2026)
- U.S.-India income tax convention (IRS)
- U.S.-Canada income tax convention and protocols (IRS)
This page summarizes public guidance in plain language. If anything here differs from the official source, the official source controls.