Retirement income comes from several tax buckets, and the order of withdrawals changes the tax bill. This guide to retirement withdrawal order sets out how taxable, pre-tax and Roth money is treated, what Illinois does, and what foreign accounts add for families with India or Canada ties. It recommends no order. The closing checklist is the Bucket-and-Border Tap Sheet.
Retirement withdrawal order: how each bucket is taxed
| Bucket | U.S. result | Source label |
|---|---|---|
| Taxable accounts | Gains on assets held over a year use the 0%, 15% or 20% rates | Rev. Proc. 2025-32 |
| Pre-tax accounts | The pre-tax part is ordinary income | Pub. 590-B |
| Roth accounts | Qualified withdrawals are not taxed | Pub. 590-B |
| NRE or NRO accounts | The U.S. taxes worldwide income, so India's exemption of NRE interest does not carry over; both can count toward FBAR and Form 8938 thresholds | RBI FAQ; U.S.-India treaty Art. 1(3) |
| RRSP, paid to a U.S. resident | Canada withholds 25% from non-residents unless a treaty lowers it; the treaty caps its tax on a periodic pension at 15% | CRA; treaty Art. XVIII(2) |
Foreign tax is claimed on Form 1116; unused credit carries back 1 year and forward 10. In Estate of Bruyea v. United States (Federal Circuit, August 31, 2026), Canadian tax could not reduce the NIIT. See our foreign tax credit guide.
How it works in numbers
A joint couple (invented) has $260,000 of income, $70,000 of it net investment income. Income over $250,000 is $10,000, so NIIT is 3.8% of $10,000 = $380. A $30,000 IRA withdrawal is not investment income but lifts income to $290,000. The excess is $40,000, less than the $70,000, so NIIT is 3.8% of $40,000 = $1,520: $1,140 more.
Planning points
- People in this situation often consider filling low brackets and the 0% gain range in lighter-income years. Trap: extra income can also trigger the NIIT, taxable Social Security and Medicare tiers.
- Others check the state first. Illinois subtracts qualified-plan and IRA income, but not private deferred pay, third-party sick pay or 10-year averaging amounts; other states vary.
- Families with foreign accounts often track which country taxed each withdrawal. Ask your adviser.
The Bucket-and-Border Tap Sheet
- List each bucket (taxable, pre-tax, Roth, foreign) with its year-end balance.
- Mark each withdrawal's tax type and the country that taxes it.
- Compare the year's income with the 0% gain top and the NIIT line.
- Note foreign tax paid, for Form 1116.
- Related: Roth conversions, our Illinois income tax guide and the group hub.
Frequently asked questions
Does Illinois tax retirement income?
Not income from qualified plans, IRAs (including converted amounts) or Social Security (Publication 120). Other states vary.
Are IRA withdrawals subject to the NIIT?
They are not net investment income, but they raise the income the NIIT thresholds use. Nonqualified annuity income is investment income.
Can Canadian tax offset the NIIT?
Not under the Federal Circuit's 2026 Bruyea ruling.
Official sources
- Revenue Procedure 2025-32, 2026 inflation adjustments
- IRS: Questions and answers on the net investment income tax
- Illinois Department of Revenue Publication 120, Retirement Income
- Canada Revenue Agency: tax rates on RRSP withdrawals
- Reserve Bank of India: FAQs on non-resident accounts
This page summarizes public guidance in plain language. If anything here differs from the official source, the official source controls.