Aurora Tax CPA
Recent cases and rulingsUSCAIN

Court of Appeals Tax Decisions 2025-2026 and Foreign Cases

Federal appeals court tax decisions of 2025 and 2026, FBAR, Form 5471 and treaty rulings first, with what each held, where review stands and Illinois rulings.

Last reviewed November 6, 2026 · Figures as of November 6, 2026 · 3 min read · General information, not tax or legal advice

General information only. Not tax, legal or investment advice. A planning idea named here is not a recommendation for any person. CPA Tax Payroll and Accounting Corp is a CPA firm, not a law firm. Tax rules change often and figures are for the tax year shown: confirm with the official source or a qualified adviser before you act. Read the full notice.

Court of appeals tax decisions set the rules inside each circuit, and three rulings from 2024 to 2026 reach foreign accounts, foreign-company forms and treaty credits. Foreign cases come first, then the rest. Place each on the Home-Circuit Pin Map below.

Slide show: Three foreign rulings in three slides

  1. Willful FBAR penalties

    Schwarzbaum (2025): the Excessive Fines Clause applies; most of the penalty stood.

  2. Form 5471 penalties

    Farhy (2024): the IRS may assess them in the D.C. Circuit. Elsewhere unsettled.

  3. Canadian tax

    Bruyea (2026): no foreign tax credit against the 3.8 percent tax.

Which court of appeals tax decisions matter most?

CaseCourt, dateHoldingWhy it matters
United States v. Schwarzbaum, No. 22-14058January 23, 2025 (11th Cir.)The Excessive Fines Clause applies, because willful FBAR penalties are substantially punitive. The court struck down $300,000 as grossly disproportional, upheld the rest, and remanded for judgment of $12,255,813 plus interest and late fees.The penalty largely stood.
Farhy v. Commissioner, 100 F.4th 223 (No. 23-1179)May 3, 2024 (D.C. Cir.)The IRS may assess, not only sue to collect, the section 6038(b) penalty for not filing Form 5471.Binds only D.C. Circuit cases. The Tax Court's contrary Mukhi case is still open; see Tax Court decisions.
Estate of Bruyea v. United States, No. 2025-1563August 31, 2026 (Fed. Cir., precedential)Canadian tax cannot offset the net investment income tax of 3.8 percent for a U.S. citizen in Canada. The Code bars the credit, and Article XXIV of the Canada treaty adds no overriding credit.The judgment for the estate was reversed. A companion France-treaty case, Christensen, came out the same way.
3M Co. v. Commissioner, No. 23-3772October 1, 2025 (8th Cir.)The IRS may reallocate only income the taxpayer controlled, so royalties Brazilian law barred stayed out of income.A Treasury regulation lost after Loper Bright. No petition was found by June 19, 2026.
Liberty Global, Inc. v. United States, No. 23-1410April 21, 2026 (10th Cir., 2-1)The codified economic substance doctrine can apply to a transaction that technically follows the Code. About $2.4 billion of section 245A deductions stayed denied.Rehearing was denied August 17, 2026.
K Alain, L.L.L.P. v. Commissioner, No. 24-60240August 12, 2026 (5th Cir.)The Tax Court's passive-investor test was rejected. A section 1402(a)(13) "limited partner" plays no significant role in managing the business.An earlier January 2026 opinion was withdrawn; do not cite it.
Soroban Capital Partners LP v. Commissioner (docket No. 25-2079(L))September 17, 2026 (2d Cir.)A partner who runs, manages or controls the business is not a limited partner for self-employment tax.A First Circuit appeal is pending; unsettled.
Bachner, Daugerdas and Hyatt Hotels (Nos. 24-1420, 25-1055, 24-3239)7th Cir.: January 7, 2025; March 30, 2026; April 22, 2026Bachner: fraud penalty on overstated withholding credits (about $394,000). Daugerdas: $371 million of criminal restitution collectible as tax. Hyatt: claim-of-right analysis required.Illinois appeals go to the Seventh Circuit. Its only published opinions in Tax Court appeals in the period.

The Home-Circuit Pin Map

  1. Pin the circuit where an appeal would go (Illinois: the Seventh).
  2. Note the ruling's date and that it binds only that circuit.
  3. Write where review stands and the date you checked.

More: how to read rulings and the cases hub.

Frequently asked questions

Does Farhy apply to me in Illinois?

It binds D.C. Circuit cases, not Seventh Circuit cases. We found no circuit ruling on the question in 2025 or 2026, so elsewhere it is unsettled. Our Form 5471 guide covers the form.

Can Canadian tax be credited against the 3.8 percent tax?

Not under Bruyea, which concerns only that tax. See foreign tax credits across three countries.

Has an appeals court applied the 2025 tax law?

We found none; the search was limited.

Official sources

This page summarizes public guidance in plain language. If anything here differs from the official source, the official source controls.