Aurora Tax CPA
Recent cases and rulingsUSCAIN

Supreme Court Tax Decisions: FBAR, Foreign Income, Deadlines

Supreme Court tax decisions from 2022 to 2026, FBAR and foreign income first: what Bittner, Moore, Zuch and Loper Bright held and what they left open.

Last reviewed November 6, 2026 · Figures as of November 6, 2026 · 3 min read · General information, not tax or legal advice

General information only. Not tax, legal or investment advice. A planning idea named here is not a recommendation for any person. CPA Tax Payroll and Accounting Corp is a CPA firm, not a law firm. Tax rules change often and figures are for the tax year shown: confirm with the official source or a qualified adviser before you act. Read the full notice.

Supreme Court tax decisions bind every federal court, so a few rulings steer how the IRS and judges treat families with accounts in India or Canada. This page lists the verified decisions from 2022 to 2026, foreign-reporting rulings first, with what each decided and left open. Test each against the Narrow-Holding Margin Note below.

Slide show: Four rulings in four slides

  1. FBAR penalties

    Bittner (2023): the non-willful maximum applies per annual report, not per account.

  2. Foreign corporations

    Moore (2024): the repatriation tax stood; realization was left open.

  3. Deadlines

    Boechler (2022): the CDP deadline can be tolled.

  4. Regulations and collection

    Loper Bright (2024) ended deference. Zuch (2025): no CDP case once the levy ends.

Which Supreme Court tax decisions matter most?

Citation and caseDecidedHoldingWhy it matters
598 U.S. 85, Bittner v. United StatesFebruary 28, 2023, 5-4A non-willful FBAR failure carries a statutory maximum of $10,000, counted per report and not per account. Five late reports, which covered 272 accounts, could not support the $2.72 million sought.Non-willful exposure is counted by annual report. Willful penalties are separate and were not decided.
602 U.S. 572, Moore v. United StatesJune 20, 2024, 7-2The section 965 repatriation tax stood, because Congress may tax U.S. owners on the realized but undistributed income of an American-controlled foreign corporation. The Court called its holding narrow.The taxpayers had invested in an Indian farm-equipment company and owed $14,729. Whether income must be realized to be taxed was left open.
596 U.S. 199, Boechler, P.C. v. CommissionerApril 21, 2022, unanimousAfter a collection due process (CDP) determination, the 30-day deadline to petition the Tax Court is not jurisdictional, so it can be equitably tolled.It began the fight over other deadlines; see penalty and procedure cases.
605 U.S. 422, Commissioner v. ZuchJune 12, 2025, 8-1Once the IRS stops pursuing the levy, the Tax Court cannot decide a CDP dispute. Overpayments had been applied until the balance was zero, so the case was dismissed.CDP is about the levy. A leftover credit or refund dispute goes to a refund suit.
603 U.S. 369, Loper Bright Enterprises v. RaimondoJune 28, 2024, 6-2Chevron is overruled. A court no longer defers to an agency because a law is ambiguous; it decides on its own whether the agency stayed within its statute. Earlier decisions upholding agency action stand.Not a tax case. Regulations stand or fall one by one; see how to read rulings.

Also verified: Enbridge (April 22, 2026, 608 U.S. 67), a non-tax case, held a removal deadline nonjurisdictional but not tollable. The First Circuit relied on it for the 90-day deficiency deadline.

The Narrow-Holding Margin Note

  1. Write the caption, citation and decision date.
  2. Copy the holding in one sentence.
  3. Add what the Court said it did not decide (Moore: realization; Bittner: willful penalties).
  4. Mark whether the case is about tax law or only procedure.
  5. Check the Court's docket for later orders before relying on the note.

Next: court of appeals decisions and the cases hub.

Frequently asked questions

Did any tax case reach a Supreme Court decision after 2024?

Yes, once on the Internal Revenue Code: Zuch, June 12, 2025. October Term 2025 had none; its rulings nearest to tax were Learning Resources (tariffs), Enbridge (a filing deadline) and Pung (property-tax sales).

Does Bittner limit FBAR penalties to one a year?

For a non-willful failure, the maximum counts each annual report once, however many accounts it lists. Willful penalties follow a separate, larger provision. Regulation 31 CFR 1010.821 adjusts the amounts: $16,536 non-willful for penalties assessed on or after January 17, 2025. See foreign reporting penalties.

Did Loper Bright cancel Treasury regulations?

No. It changed how courts review them, and earlier decisions that upheld agency action keep their force as precedent.

Official sources

This page summarizes public guidance in plain language. If anything here differs from the official source, the official source controls.