A fixed vs variable vs indexed annuity decision is mostly a question of who carries investment risk, because all four types are taxed under one set of income tax rules. An annuity is a contract: you hand an insurer money, and it pays income starting now (immediate) or later (deferred). This page covers deferred contracts from U.S. insurers. Run each quote through the Risk Seat Chart below. General information only; we sell no insurance and recommend no product.
Fixed vs variable vs indexed annuity: the comparison
| Type | Who carries market risk | Regulated as |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed, including contracts sold as MYGA (a set rate for a fixed number of years, followed by a renewal rate) | The insurer | Insurance product, state regulator |
| Fixed indexed | Shared: upside is capped, the insurer takes market losses | Insurance product, state regulator |
| RILA | Shared: the insurer takes losses inside a buffer or beyond a floor; the owner bears the rest | Security (SEC) and insurance (state) |
| Variable | The owner | Security (SEC) and insurance (state) |
How crediting works in numbers (invented terms)
On a $50,000 contract, each rule applied alone:
| Rule | Index move | Credit | On $50,000 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 60 percent participation | +8% | +4.8% | +$2,400 |
| 5 percent cap | +8% | +5% | +$2,500 |
| 2 percent spread | +8% | +6% | +$3,000 |
| 10 percent buffer (RILA) | -15% | -5% | -$2,500 |
| 10 percent floor (RILA) | -15% | -10% | -$5,000 |
| Zero floor (fixed indexed) | -15% | 0% | $0 |
Index dividends are usually left out, and insurers can usually reset caps and rates.
Planning points
Readers comparing contracts often consider:
- Asking which type a quote really is and who absorbs a market loss. Trap: a brand name does not tell you.
- Asking for the crediting limits and whether the insurer may reset them. Trap: this year's cap is not next year's.
- Asking about exit costs and what a rider withdrawal does. Trap: taking money out may shrink a benefit by more than the sum withdrawn.
- Treating tax as a tie: the choice rests on risk, cost and access to money.
- Treating a contract issued abroad as a separate question; start with our foreign retirement and savings guide and the FBAR guide.
The Risk Seat Chart
- Who sits in the risk seat: insurer, you, or both?
- What the insurer owes, and what backs it.
- What limits your upside: cap, participation rate, spread.
- What it costs: explicit fees or costs hidden in credited rates.
- How you leave: surrender schedule, market value adjustment (cautions).
See also the tax page, the exchange page and the annuities hub.
Frequently asked questions
Is a MYGA taxed differently from other fixed annuities?
No. The label describes a rate term, not a tax category.
Can I lose money in an indexed annuity?
A fixed indexed credit does not fall below zero in a period, but exit charges can still cut what you receive. A RILA credit can be negative.
Do variable annuity gains get capital gain rates?
No. Ordinary income rates apply, as with the other types.
Official sources
- SEC Investor.gov, Annuities
- SEC Investor Bulletin, Indexed Annuities (31 July 2020)
- FINRA, Annuities
- NAIC, Annuities topic page
- IRC section 72, Annuities (Cornell LII)
This page summarizes public guidance in plain language. If anything here differs from the official source, the official source controls.