Annuity surrender charges are only the first cost to check. Market value adjustments, fees, a 10 percent early tax, the 3.8 percent net investment income tax (NIIT) and no basis step-up for heirs can follow. Test any purchase, withdrawal or exchange with the Stair-Step Cost Review at the end. General information only.
Annuity surrender charges and other rules
| Point | Plain meaning | Source |
|---|---|---|
| NIIT base | Annuity payments and section 72(e) withdrawals are net investment income. IRA and plan payments are not, but they raise MAGI | IRC 1411(c)(1)(A)(i), (c)(5); Reg. 1.1411-8; Reg. 1.1411-1(d)(1) |
| Inherited annuity | No step-up; the gain reaches heirs as income in respect of a decedent. If the owner dies before payouts, heirs use the 5-year rule, life-expectancy payments within a year, or spousal continuation | Rev. Rul. 2005-30; IRC 72(s), 1014(b)(9)(A), (c) |
| Illinois guaranty | Annuity benefits are covered to $250,000 in present value per life, and generally $300,000 across all coverage; uncredited index interest is excluded | 215 ILCS 5/531.03, 531.19 |
| Sales standards | Illinois Part 3120 (as amended 3 February 2023) sets care and disclosure duties, not a fiduciary duty. The 2024 DOL fiduciary rule was vacated (DOL notice, 20 March 2026) | 50 Ill. Adm. Code 3120; 91 FR 13503 |
When your life crosses borders
| Situation | Result | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Nonresident alien | The NIIT does not apply | IRC 1411(e)(1) |
| Foreign earned income exclusion | The excluded amount is generally added back to MAGI | IRC 1411(d) |
| U.S. citizen in Canada | Canadian tax cannot be credited against the NIIT; the treaty adds no override (further review still possible; Canada treaty guide) | Estate of Bruyea (Fed. Cir. 31 August 2026) |
| Owner who moves abroad | Illinois tests residence when a court finds the insurer impaired or insolvent; U.S. citizens abroad count as residents of the insurer's domicile state; other non-residents are covered only on listed conditions | 215 ILCS 5/531.03(1), 531.05 |
How it works in numbers (invented example, 2026)
A married couple filing jointly has $210,000 of wages and $4,000 of interest. They surrender a non-qualified annuity worth $190,000 on $120,000 of investment: $70,000 of gain.
- MAGI: $284,000, which is $34,000 over $250,000. Net investment income: $74,000. NIIT: 3.8 percent of $34,000 = $1,292.
- Without the surrender: MAGI $214,000, NIIT $0.
- If the $70,000 came from a traditional IRA: NIIT = 3.8 percent of $4,000 = $152.
Planning points
People weighing a purchase or an exit often consider:
- Asking for the surrender schedule and adjustment formula in writing. Trap: a free-withdrawal allowance removes the charge, not the tax.
- Checking whether one large gain crosses the NIIT line or erodes the senior deduction (temporary, tax years 2025 to 2028; phased out at 6 percent of MAGI over $75,000, or $150,000 joint).
- Remembering that 2026 income can reach 2028 Medicare premiums. We handle the U.S. side and coordinate with your Canadian CPA or Indian CA.
The Stair-Step Cost Review
- Exit costs: surrender schedule, free withdrawals, adjustment.
- Running costs: fees, riders.
- Tax costs: ordinary income, 10 percent, NIIT.
- Heir costs: no step-up.
- Safety net: guaranty limits, residence.
See taxation of withdrawals and the annuities hub.
Frequently asked questions
Does the NIIT apply to an annuity inside my IRA?
No, but taxable IRA payouts still raise MAGI.
Do heirs get a stepped-up basis on an inherited annuity?
No; the heir is taxed on the gain.
Does the guaranty association cover everything?
No. Dollar limits and exclusions apply, and it cannot be used as a selling point.
Official sources
- IRC section 1411, Net investment income tax (Cornell LII)
- Estate of Bruyea v. United States, No. 2025-1563 (Fed. Cir. 31 August 2026)
- 215 ILCS 5/531.03, Illinois guaranty association coverage and limits
- SEC Investor.gov, Annuities
- NAIC, Buyer's Guide for Deferred Annuities
This page summarizes public guidance in plain language. If anything here differs from the official source, the official source controls.