Aurora Tax CPA
Recent cases and rulingsUSCAIN

FBAR Penalty and Tax Deadline Cases: Bittner to Kyick

FBAR penalty cases and tax deadline rulings from 2022 to 2026: Bittner, Schwarzbaum, Farhy, Mukhi and the circuits that split on the 90-day petition deadline.

Last reviewed November 6, 2026 · Figures as of November 6, 2026 · 3 min read · General information, not tax or legal advice

General information only. Not tax, legal or investment advice. A planning idea named here is not a recommendation for any person. CPA Tax Payroll and Accounting Corp is a CPA firm, not a law firm. Tax rules change often and figures are for the tax year shown: confirm with the official source or a qualified adviser before you act. Read the full notice.

FBAR penalty cases turn on counting, and the other penalty and procedure rulings of 2022 to 2026 turn on dates. This page puts the foreign-reporting penalty rulings first, then the 90-day petition deadline on which circuits disagree. Run each through the Pencil-and-Postmark Penalty Pass below.

Slide show: Three penalty lessons in three slides

  1. Count reports

    Non-willful FBAR exposure is counted per report, not per account.

  2. Willful is different

    Willful penalties are separate.

  3. Calendar first

    Circuits disagree on tolling the 90-day deadline. File on time.

How do FBAR penalty cases count in numbers?

Under Bittner v. United States, 598 U.S. 85 (February 28, 2023), the Supreme Court counted non-willful penalties per report. Invented example: Meera, a green-card holder in Batavia, missed two annual FBARs without willfulness, each listing six accounts in India and Canada. A per-account count would give 2 x 6 x $16,536 = $198,432. The per-report rule gives 2 x $16,536 = $33,072 as the maximum. The IRS may assess less, and willful penalties follow a separate provision.

Which penalty and procedure rulings matter?

Appeals caseCourt and dateWhat it heldWhy it matters
United States v. Schwarzbaum, No. 22-1405811th Cir., January 23, 2025The Excessive Fines Clause applies to willful FBAR penalties. The court struck $300,000 as grossly disproportional and upheld the rest.No petition for Supreme Court review found.
Farhy v. Commissioner, 100 F.4th 223D.C. Cir., May 3, 2024The IRS may assess the section 6038(b) penalty for not filing Form 5471.Mukhi, below, differs for a case appealable to the Eighth Circuit.
Buller; Oquendo; Maniktala; Kyick Holdings2d Cir., August 14, 2025 (amended November 26); 6th Cir., August 25, 2025; 8th Cir., August 11, 2026; 1st Cir., August 17, 2026The 90-day deficiency deadline (section 6213(a)) is nonjurisdictional. The first three circuits allow equitable tolling. Kyick does not, partly relying on Enbridge, and affirmed dismissal of a petition filed 143 days late.A split. No petition found. In circuits that have not ruled, the Tax Court still treats the deadline as jurisdictional.
Tax Court caseCourt and dateWhat it heldWhy it matters
Mukhi v. Commissioner, 163 T.C. No. 8November 18, 2024In a case appealable to the Eighth Circuit, which had not ruled, the IRS lacks authority to assess the section 6038(b)(1) penalty.The docket is still open; unsettled.
Kings Road, 167 T.C. No. 11; North Wall, 165 T.C. No. 9; Belagio, 164 T.C. No. 7September 21, 2026; October 21, 2025; April 15, 2025Partnership adjustment petitions can be tolled, and were where the IRS told counsel no notice had been mailed. TEFRA periods cannot. A worker-classification petition sent by an undesignated FedEx service arrived one day late; tolling was denied.Deadlines are sorted statute by statute.

The Pencil-and-Postmark Penalty Pass

  1. Pencil: count missed annual reports, not accounts.
  2. Pencil: ask which penalty provision, non-willful or willful, is in play.
  3. Postmark: write the notice date, the ninetieth day and the circuit.
  4. Postmark: do not plan on tolling.

More: Supreme Court decisions, planning lessons and the cases hub.

Frequently asked questions

Do FBAR penalties apply to each account?

For a non-willful failure, no: the maximum is counted per annual report. Willful penalties are separate and can be far larger. See foreign reporting penalties.

Can tolling save a late Tax Court petition?

Only where the circuit and the statute allow it, and not in the First Circuit for the 90-day deficiency deadline. File on time. Other relief: penalty abatement playbook.

Is Farhy the last word on Form 5471 penalties?

No. It binds D.C. Circuit cases, and the Tax Court in Mukhi went the other way for a case appealable to the Eighth Circuit.

Official sources

This page summarizes public guidance in plain language. If anything here differs from the official source, the official source controls.