FBAR penalty cases turn on counting, and the other penalty and procedure rulings of 2022 to 2026 turn on dates. This page puts the foreign-reporting penalty rulings first, then the 90-day petition deadline on which circuits disagree. Run each through the Pencil-and-Postmark Penalty Pass below.
How do FBAR penalty cases count in numbers?
Under Bittner v. United States, 598 U.S. 85 (February 28, 2023), the Supreme Court counted non-willful penalties per report. Invented example: Meera, a green-card holder in Batavia, missed two annual FBARs without willfulness, each listing six accounts in India and Canada. A per-account count would give 2 x 6 x $16,536 = $198,432. The per-report rule gives 2 x $16,536 = $33,072 as the maximum. The IRS may assess less, and willful penalties follow a separate provision.
Which penalty and procedure rulings matter?
| Appeals case | Court and date | What it held | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| United States v. Schwarzbaum, No. 22-14058 | 11th Cir., January 23, 2025 | The Excessive Fines Clause applies to willful FBAR penalties. The court struck $300,000 as grossly disproportional and upheld the rest. | No petition for Supreme Court review found. |
| Farhy v. Commissioner, 100 F.4th 223 | D.C. Cir., May 3, 2024 | The IRS may assess the section 6038(b) penalty for not filing Form 5471. | Mukhi, below, differs for a case appealable to the Eighth Circuit. |
| Buller; Oquendo; Maniktala; Kyick Holdings | 2d Cir., August 14, 2025 (amended November 26); 6th Cir., August 25, 2025; 8th Cir., August 11, 2026; 1st Cir., August 17, 2026 | The 90-day deficiency deadline (section 6213(a)) is nonjurisdictional. The first three circuits allow equitable tolling. Kyick does not, partly relying on Enbridge, and affirmed dismissal of a petition filed 143 days late. | A split. No petition found. In circuits that have not ruled, the Tax Court still treats the deadline as jurisdictional. |
| Tax Court case | Court and date | What it held | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mukhi v. Commissioner, 163 T.C. No. 8 | November 18, 2024 | In a case appealable to the Eighth Circuit, which had not ruled, the IRS lacks authority to assess the section 6038(b)(1) penalty. | The docket is still open; unsettled. |
| Kings Road, 167 T.C. No. 11; North Wall, 165 T.C. No. 9; Belagio, 164 T.C. No. 7 | September 21, 2026; October 21, 2025; April 15, 2025 | Partnership adjustment petitions can be tolled, and were where the IRS told counsel no notice had been mailed. TEFRA periods cannot. A worker-classification petition sent by an undesignated FedEx service arrived one day late; tolling was denied. | Deadlines are sorted statute by statute. |
The Pencil-and-Postmark Penalty Pass
- Pencil: count missed annual reports, not accounts.
- Pencil: ask which penalty provision, non-willful or willful, is in play.
- Postmark: write the notice date, the ninetieth day and the circuit.
- Postmark: do not plan on tolling.
More: Supreme Court decisions, planning lessons and the cases hub.
Frequently asked questions
Do FBAR penalties apply to each account?
For a non-willful failure, no: the maximum is counted per annual report. Willful penalties are separate and can be far larger. See foreign reporting penalties.
Can tolling save a late Tax Court petition?
Only where the circuit and the statute allow it, and not in the First Circuit for the 90-day deficiency deadline. File on time. Other relief: penalty abatement playbook.
Is Farhy the last word on Form 5471 penalties?
No. It binds D.C. Circuit cases, and the Tax Court in Mukhi went the other way for a case appealable to the Eighth Circuit.
Official sources
- Bittner v. United States, Supreme Court, February 28, 2023
- United States v. Schwarzbaum, 11th Cir., January 23, 2025
- Buller v. Commissioner, 2d Cir., amended opinion of November 26, 2025
- Maniktala v. Commissioner, 8th Cir., opinion of August 11, 2026
- 31 CFR 1010.821, civil penalty amounts (eCFR)
This page summarizes public guidance in plain language. If anything here differs from the official source, the official source controls.